When silence doesn’t mean comfort: Caring for unresponsive dying residents at end-of-life

Wednesday, 18 November 2026
4 mins

Article written by Tricia O’Connor, RN, PhD candidate, College of Health and Enablement, Flinders University

Residential aged care staff support for some of the most vulnerable people in our community, including many in the final days and hours of life. While death is common in aged care, caring for a dying resident is not always straightforward, particularly when the resident can no longer communicate their needs.

As one palliative care nurse in our recent research (1) explained:

“…your palliative care patient who’s actively dying in the terminal phase is not your easiest patient; they’re just your quietest patient.”

This simple statement highlights an important challenge for nurses and care workers. When a resident can no longer tell us they are in pain, uncomfortable, frightened, or distressed, how do we know what they need?

Our recent research explored how experienced palliative care nurses make decisions when caring for dying people who have become unresponsive. The findings are particularly relevant to residential aged care, where nurses and care workers are often responsible for supporting residents and their family through the final stages of life.

When residents can no longer tell us what they need

For many years, nurses have been taught that pain is what the patient says it is. The same principle applies to many other symptoms. Ideally, the person experiencing the symptom tells us what they are feeling, how severe it is, and whether our interventions are helping. But what happens when that person can no longer communicate?

Previous research (2) has suggested that around half of dying people become unresponsive before death, often for about two days. During this time, residents may no longer be able to verbalise pain, discomfort, breathlessness, anxiety, or other symptoms that require management. The absence of communication, however, should not be mistaken for the absence of symptoms.

Nurses in our study consistently emphasised that residents remain the focus of decision-making, even when they can no longer speak for themselves. Becoming unresponsive does not mean a person no longer has physical, emotional, or spiritual needs. Rather, it requires nurses and care workers to find different ways of identifying those needs.

Looking for the subtle signs

The nurses we interviewed described decision-making as a process of gathering pieces of information from multiple sources and putting them together, much like completing a puzzle. They drew on their assessment skills, clinical experience, observations, professional intuition, and discussions with colleagues. Rather than relying on a single sign, they combined multiple observations to guide decisions about care. Importantly, nurses actively looked for subtle indicators that a resident might be experiencing discomfort.

A resident who appears peaceful while resting in bed may grimace when repositioned. Another may become tense during personal care or vocalise softly when moved. These small changes may provide important clues that the person is experiencing pain or distress but is unable to communicate it directly. The nurses described the need to actively seek out these signs rather than assuming that silence equals comfort.

The important role of care workers

One finding relevant to residential aged care was the value of observations from those who know the resident best. Personal care workers often spend more one-on-one time with residents than any other member of the care team. Through daily interactions, they become familiar with residents’ usual behaviours, expressions, and responses. This familiarity means they may be the first to notice subtle changes that suggest discomfort or distress.

Encouraging care workers to share these observations can strengthen decision-making and help ensure important signs are not overlooked. It can also help prepare care workers for the dying process and support their confidence in caring for residents at the end of life.

Supporting families through uncertainty

Families also play an important role during this stage of care. For many family members, this may be their first experience witnessing someone die. The uncertainty surrounding the dying process can create fear, distress, and concern about whether their loved one is comfortable.

The nurses in our study described the importance of clear, compassionate communication with families. Explaining expected changes, discussing uncertainty openly, and involving families in decision-making with the resident remaining at the centre of all decisions, can help reduce anxiety and build trust.

Managing uncertainty

Uncertainty was a recurring theme throughout the study. Just as no two people experience life in the same way, no two people experience dying in the same way. Nurses discussed uncertainty about when death might occur, and the causes of possible discomfort. When concerns arose, they described systematically considering common causes of distress such as pain, constipation, urinary retention, or breathing difficulties. Repositioning the resident and conducting further assessment were often among their first actions.

Nurses also highlighted the value of anticipatory prescribing. Having medications available for expected end-of-life symptoms enabled them to respond promptly when symptoms were suspected.

What can clinicians do?

When caring for an unresponsive dying resident:

  • Remember that quiet does not necessarily mean comfortable.
  • Continue to treat the resident as the central focus of care and decision-making.
  • Look carefully for subtle non-verbal signs of discomfort or distress.
  • Encourage care workers to share their observations and concerns.
  • Communicate openly with families about what is happening and what to expect.
  • Consider common causes of discomfort and assess systematically.
  • Ensure appropriate end-of-life medications are prescribed and available when needed.
  • Seek support from experienced colleagues when uncertainty exists.

Caring for an unresponsive resident requires nurses to make important decisions without being able to ask the person directly what they need. Our research suggests these decisions are rarely based on a single observation. Instead, nurses draw together assessment findings, experience, family perspectives, observations from care workers, and their understanding of the dying process.

While uncertainty can never be completely eliminated, one message is clear: the quietest resident may still need us to listen most carefully.

For more information, ELDAC Manage Dying provides information on signs to look out for when someone is in their final days of life as well as tools that can help identify and manage symptoms.

References:
  1. O’Connor T, Collier A, Strickland K, Thamm C, Paterson C. When dying patients fall silent: How nurses navigate decision-making in the last days of life – a qualitative study. J Adv Nurs. 2026;1-4.
  2. O’Connor T, Liu W-M, Samara J, Lewis J, Strickland K, Paterson C. Determining timeframes to death for imminently dying patients: A retrospective cohort study. BMC Palliat Care. 2025;24, 12.

Author

Tricia O'Connor

RN, PhD candidate

College of Health and Enablement, Flinders University

Page updated 18 November 2026